The Florida migrant gulag is what occurs when the depravities of colonialist international coverage are turned inward.
A Florida Freeway Patrol officer appears to be like on as protesters collect to demand the closure of the immigrant detention middle generally known as “Alligator Alcatraz” on the Dade-Collier Coaching and Transition Airport in Ochopee, Florida, on July 22, 2025.
(Chandan Khanna / AFP by way of Getty Pictures)
They’re calling it “Alligator Alcatraz”—a sprawling migrant detention middle deep within the Florida wetlands, surrounded by flood zones, razor wire, and a way of menace. Crawling with each literal and governmental predators, it was constructed not simply to course of however to intimidate. ICE buses arrive every day. Surveillance cameras and National Guard patrols clarify: It is a jail, not a sanctuary. These deemed “unwelcome” on this nation will probably be caged right here and forgotten.
Officers declare the power will redefine the deportation pipeline. They’re proper—simply not how they assume. That’s as a result of Alligator Alcatraz isn’t a brand new invention. It’s the newest incarnation of a system designed to not welcome the displaced however to include, punish, and erase them. It’s the logical endpoint of many years of militarized US coverage at residence and overseas.
In June, President Trump bypassed California’s governor and deployed Marines and Nationwide Guard troops to Los Angeles to help ICE raids in residential neighborhoods. Army personnel patrolled college drop-offs and hospitals. Cameras rolled as households have been separated on sidewalks. Days later, Trump publicly suggested that Zohran Mamdani—a US citizen and New York mayoral candidate of South Asian descent—must be arrested and deported.
This isn’t a glitch within the system. It’s the system—warnings embedded in spectacle.
We aren’t witnessing a sudden surge in xenophobia. We’re witnessing the convergence of histories—immigration enforcement, racial management, and international coverage merging into one carceral undertaking. The result’s a home counterinsurgency machine, refined over many years, now turned inward.
Begin in Guatemala, 1954. The CIA overthrew Jacobo Árbenz after he threatened to redistribute land and lower into US enterprise pursuits. The coup plunged the nation right into a civil battle that lasted 36 years, killed greater than 200,000 folks, and despatched refugees fleeing north. A lot of these refugees or their descendants might now face detention or deportation.
Present Difficulty
The sample repeated throughout the area. The US-backed ousting of Salvador Allende in Chile. The civil battle in El Salvador, the place American funded armed loss of life squads and displaced practically 1 / 4 of the inhabitants. In Honduras, the 2009 US-backed coup sparked a political collapse that’s nonetheless driving tens of hundreds north to the border annually.
These migrations hint the scars of US international coverage. As historian Greg Grandin writes, Latin America grew to become “empire’s workshop”—a testing floor for counterinsurgency ways that may finally return residence.
When migrants arrive on the southern border, they’re crossing fault traces created by the US by way of navy help, financial coercion, and covert operations. The so-called border disaster isn’t the product of random chaos. It’s the empire’s return circulate.
Within the Nineteen Eighties, Chilly Conflict logic fused with the Conflict on Medicine. Surveillance expanded. Native police have been militarized. Poor and immigrant neighborhoods have been redefined as menace zones. After 9/11, issues intensified once more. Strategies refined in Iraq and Afghanistan— biometric monitoring, drone surveillance, predictive policing—have been imported wholesale into immigration enforcement. ICE, DHS, and CBP absorbed a wartime logic.
And with them got here the architects of battle itself.
Behind the biometric gates of Alligator Alcatraz lie the fingerprints of America’s strongest protection contractors. Raytheon, Palantir, and Lockheed Martin— corporations as soon as identified for cruise missiles and drone strikes—now supply the surveillance, facial recognition software program, and digital monitoring instruments used to police the immigrants.
Fashionable
“swipe left under to view extra authors”Swipe →
These surveillance applied sciences don’t originate in a vacuum. Many are examined and refined in occupied Palestine, the place Israel has developed and exported a mannequin of management constructed on biometric monitoring, predictive policing, and everlasting militarization. US businesses like ICE and DHS have engaged in joint coaching with Israeli safety forces, importing not solely ways however an ideology of whole management over racialized populations. Corporations like Elbit Techniques, which constructed surveillance know-how in and round Israel’s separation wall, now present surveillance towers and sensors for the US-Mexico border. The occupation of Palestine capabilities as a laboratory—the place methods of domination are sharpened earlier than being deployed at residence.
These engines of containment function with bipartisan blessing.
From Reagan to Clinton, Bush to Biden, the strategy has remained largely the identical: deal with migration as a menace to include, not a consequence to grasp. Criminalization turns into the default. Enforcement turns into coverage. And budgets balloon accordingly.
President Obama—regardless of his reformist rhetoric—deported extra immigrants than any president in US historical past, earning the nickname “Deporter in Chief” from immigrant rights advocates. His administration expanded detention quotas, surveillance packages, and legal frameworks that future presidents would inherit and escalate. Although he later narrowed priorities to deal with severe offenders and up to date arrivals, the shift got here too late—and with out dismantling the underlying equipment.
That fortified system was handed to Trump, who wasted no time weaponizing it—turning immigration into theater, threatening naturalized residents, and staging mass raids for cable information consumption. However the logic of punishment over safety, of surveillance over sanctuary, didn’t begin with Trump—and it didn’t finish with him.
Now, below his second time period, the infrastructure is metastasizing. In July, the administration offered $608 million to states prepared to duplicate Florida’s detention mannequin—an incentive for governors to construct their very own Alligator Alcatrazes utilizing fast-track emergency powers. Texas, Arizona, and Louisiana have all expressed curiosity. Florida’s prototype—inbuilt simply eight days with $245 million in federal contracts—is a deterrence mannequin packaged for nationwide rollout.
Right this moment, over 56,000 individuals are held in ICE detention on any given evening—a document excessive and a 40 p.c improve over final yr. Practically 72 p.c have no criminal history. With overcrowding mounting, studies of bodily and emotional abuse proliferate: migrants forced to stand within the blazing solar for hours, held in disgusting and unsafe conditions, denied legal counsel, and separated from youngsters with out clear reunification plans. These are recurring options of a system optimized for disorientation. And nonetheless, the budgets swell. Tons of of hundreds of thousands materialize for fast development and mass detention, whereas requires livable wages, healthcare, or functioning faculties are met with shrugs and spreadsheets.
The query isn’t how we afford care—solely why we preserve selecting cages.
Final month, Congress passed the One Huge Stunning Invoice Act, a sweeping spending measure that slashes funding for Medicaid and SNAP whereas allocating practically $170 billion to immigration enforcement—making ICE the largest federal law enforcement agency. A large share of that funding will circulate to non-public jail operators and protection contractors behind detention websites like Alligator Alcatraz. That is intentional. Caging the displaced is now a bipartisan finances precedence.
This isn’t about safety. It’s about funding—in worry, in punishment, in revenue.
As historian Kelly Lytle Hernández reminds us, ICE’s ancestry traces again to slave patrols and colonial policing. What as soon as pursued the enslaved now targets the displaced. The instruments have advanced—drones as an alternative of canine, algorithms as an alternative of chains—however the goal stays the identical: seize and management.
And more and more, even dissent turns into a deportable offense. Authorized observers have documented ICE raids at churches, schools, and hospitals. Households torn aside not accidentally, however by technique. The purpose isn’t simply elimination. It’s worry.
I’ve spoken with migrant employees who say immediately’s worry mirrors the violence they as soon as fled. The helicopters have been American then, too—simply flown by others. Now they hover over US cities with the identical intent: detain, divide, disappear.
But, even below these situations, resistance endures. Detainees stage starvation strikes. Authorized advocates sue. Communities construct rapid-response networks and mutual help programs. However the machine grinds on.
Thinker Aimé Césaire warned that colonial violence at all times boomerangs again residence. Hannah Arendt cautioned that totalitarianism begins when imperial strategies flip inward—when total populations are solid as inside enemies.
We’ve reached that second. A nation that when exported counterinsurgency now enacts it on home soil.
Alligator Alcatraz just isn’t an outlier. It’s a sign flare.
The surveillance state that when patrolled Fallujah now displays Fresno. The protection contractors that when armed international insurgencies now handle migrant detention contracts. The authorized structure that when interned Japanese Individuals now justifies raids on faculties and mosques.
Immigration enforcement just isn’t damaged. It’s working precisely because it was designed to—to self-discipline labor, suppress dissent, and reinforce a racial and financial order.
We should cease asking how you can repair a system constructed to punish. We should ask why we preserve paying for it—in Congress, in budgets, in silence, and in complicity.
As a result of when empire turns inward, it doesn’t simply goal migrants. It targets the nation’s soul.
“Empire overseas entails tyranny at residence,” Arendt warned us. The tyranny has landed.
On this second of disaster, we’d like a unified, progressive opposition to Donald Trump.
We’re beginning to see one take form within the streets and at poll containers throughout the nation: from New York Metropolis mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani’s marketing campaign targeted on affordability, to communities defending their neighbors from ICE, to the senators opposing arms shipments to Israel.
The Democratic Get together has an pressing option to make: Will it embrace a politics that’s principled and common, or will it proceed to insist on shedding elections with the out-of-touch elites and consultants that acquired us right here?
At The Nation, we all know which facet we’re on. Day-after-day, we make the case for a extra democratic and equal world by championing progressive leaders, lifting up actions preventing for justice, and exposing the oligarchs and firms profiting on the expense of us all. Our unbiased journalism informs and empowers progressives throughout the nation and helps convey this politics to new readers prepared to hitch the struggle.
We’d like your assist to proceed this work. Will you donate to help The Nation’s unbiased journalism? Each contribution goes to our award-winning reporting, evaluation, and commentary.
Thanks for serving to us tackle Trump and construct the simply society we all know is feasible.
Sincerely,
Bhaskar Sunkara
President, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
Something is feasible within the coming days and weeks, but it surely’s troublesome to not really feel like we’re veering towards escalating violence.
Trump compels his followers to endorse apparent lies. It’s accelerating the nation’s descent into authoritarianism.
The symbolism of the Border Patrol’s gratuitous show wasn’t misplaced on the management of the Japanese American Nationwide Museum, the place the occasion was held.